Many dogs struggle a lot with crate training. How should you respond when your dog barks non-stop in his kennel?
In today’s Ask a Behavior Consultant, we’re tackling the following query from our reader:
“My 7 month old Chihuahua -I just got him this Saturday- won’t stop barking in his kennel, we’ve tried everything. I’ve put a blanket over his kennel, ignored him and everything. If we don’t get this together I’m going to have to get rid of him, please help.”
– Sincerely, Non-Stop Barker
If you’re dealing with a dog who barks non-stop in their kennel, be sure to check out the following resources from Journey Dog Training:
- Crate Training Basics
- Should I crate train my puppy if he hates the crate?
- Reasons why your dog barks when left alone
- Our 15-minute and one-hour phone consultations or video training sessions.
I’ve crate trained a lot of dogs, and I know firsthand how hard it can be to deal with a dog who barks non-stop in his kennel.
I’m glad that our reader was so proactive by seeking help for her dog’s crate-barking problem right away!
That said, I hope she’s able to stick with this puzzle for a bit. Most training problems aren’t fixable in just a few days. When she wrote to me, she’d only had the dog for three days. Fixing most behavior problems will take more time than that!
Let’s get into how to teach a dog to stop barking in his kennel.
Why Does My Dog Bark Non-Stop in His Kennel?
There are many reasons your pup might bark nonstop in his crate. We’ll explore what to do about each situation below, but for now let’s take a peek at what might be causing the problem!
Your Dog Isn’t Fully Crate Trained
Consider whether or not the dog NEEDS to be in the crate. In some cases, the easiest option is to ease up a bit on crate training and do small training sessions, teaching it like an endurance skill. Dogs don’t naturally sleep in the crate for 4+ hours without training, just like you can’t meditate for an hour without a bit of practice. This is ESPECIALLY true with young dogs.
Simply closing the dog in a crate and ignoring him is likely to backfire.
It’s also worth considering WHEN the dog is barking in his kennel. Is it truly 24/7, or is the problem worse at specific times?
Your Dog is Experiencing FOMO
For example, dogs that bark when they can see or hear you may be experiencing some frustration that’s akin to FOMO (fear of missing out). My puppy Niffler actually barked the most if I was playing with Barley (my other dog), but slept nicely if he was alone. It took a few weeks for him to even relax when I was reading on the other side of the room because he wanted to join the fun! I mostly crate-trained him by sitting right next to him in the crate and rewarding calm behaviors. Over time, I could move further and further from his crate.
Your Pup Isn’t Tired Yet
I was also careful not to put him in the crate unless he was genuinely tired and relaxed. If he was overly tired, sometimes we got MORE barking and fussing (just like a tired toddler who REALLY needs a nap).
Your Dog Suffers from Separation Anxiety
Meanwhile, dogs that bark most when left alone may be experiencing separation anxiety. Dogs that bark before settling in need to address a crate training deficit, while dogs that bark after a long time in the crate may simply need to go potty or get some exercise. This last group of dogs really deserves to be let out; it’s not fair to ignore a dog who’s communicating a genuine need.
Should You Ignore A Dog Barking in His Crate?
Generally, we do not recommend letting dogs “cry it out.” Ignoring a dog that’s barking in his crate will teach him that being closed in the crate is bad and lonely; he’s learning that you ignore his needs and he may start to panic in the crate even more.
That’s not to say that ANY squeaking or crying merits a release from the crate. A bit of fussing is pretty normal and can be safely ignored. But if your pup is barking more than normal or seems truly upset, it’s time to react.
Rather than ignoring your barking dog, teach him that barking in his crate gets him one response and one response only: a leashed excursion to the back yard for 1-2 minutes, then a return to his crate. This is a great way to teach your dog to bark if he genuinely needs to pee, but not to cry for attention or playtime. Try to be neutral and calm and don’t play as you take him outside.
However, all of this assumes that your dog is well-exercised and has his needs met. If your dog is cooped up and bored, it’s not really ethical to leave him in his crate and ignore him when he’s out.
Part of why I don’t recommend ignoring a barking dog in a crate is ethical (I don’t like teaching my dogs that I’ll ignore them if they’re distressed), and part of it is practical: imagine that usually your dog barks three times before you let him out of the crate, but now you’ve decided to ignore his barking. What happens next is called an extinction burst.
How Long Should You Let a Dog Bark in the Crate?
The answer depends on the TYPE of barking more than the length of time.
With my puppy Niffler, I generally ignored low-level whimpering or a few seconds of fussing. If he barked, I took him outside for a quick potty break then returned him to the crate for a couple treats. I tried to let him out as soon as he woke up from a nap, BEFORE he started to bark. Catching him being good is a key to teaching him to be quiet in the crate!
You’ll need to get to know what’s normal for your dog. Remember that young puppies (under 6 months old) are BABIES and will need frequent reassurance and potty breaks. They deserve comfort and support, not to be ignored.
Is Your Dog Barking for Attention or For Needs?
Whenever my puppy Niffler started barking in his crate, I tried to assess what he really needed. How long had it been since his last potty break? Was he hungry? Thirsty? Bored and cooped up?
In some cases, he genuinely had all of his needs met and just wanted more attention. In this case, I either ignored him or walked away. I found that getting up and walking away (rather than simply ignoring him) actually helped the issue faster.
However, this can be risky if you don’t truly assess your pup’s needs. Once, I got up and walked away because I was certain Niffler just wanted attention. I came back to find a HUGE puddle on the ground – he’d desperately needed to pee! I’d misjudged how much water he’d had after our last play session.
If my dog just got a play session and a potty break but is still barking in his crate, I’ll likely settle down near his crate and read to help him settle down. If that happens repeatedly, I’d start giving him a long-lasting chew the moment I put him in the crate so he can transition from playtime to chewtime to bedtime more smoothly.
If you find your dog barking at you consistently in the crate, it’s time to reassess your current schedule and plan – it’s not working!
How to Stop a Dog from Barking Non-Stop in His Kennel
This owner said that she’d tried putting a blanket over the dog’s kennel and ignoring the dog. Those techniques are quite common. They also are not always the best tactics.
Sure, some dogs will quiet down when their kennel is dark. Other dogs will give up if their barking is ignored. But many dogs don’t give up so easily! Here’s what I’d suggest doing instead:
- Ensure your dog is ready to be crated. If your dog has been sleeping all night and you try to put her back in the crate after a 20 minute walk, you’re setting her up to fail. Ensure that your dog is fulfilled, enriched, and ready to nap. If you need to put your pup away but they’re not tired enough yet, use an exercise pen (see #4).
- Consider crate setup. Ensure your dog’s crate is big enough and super-comfy. Some dogs prefer a big squishy bed and covered crate while others prefer a wire crate and cooling mat. Simply moving your crate to be right next to your desk during the day or bed at night often soothes a barking dog. White noise or dog appeasing pheromone (DAP) can help as well, but don’t expect those two changes to fix it all.
- You can then gradually move the crate to wherever you need it to be – but start out with success by putting the crate close to you where you can reward your pup for being quiet. Once you’ve got success there, we can move toward the final location for the crate! I put Niffler’s crate ON my bed for his first few nights at home. Soon his crate was at the foot of my bed, then tucked beside the couch where I wanted it to be.
- Make the crate an awesome place to be. Use puzzle toys and Karen Overall’s Relaxation protocol to teach your dog to quietly and calmly hang out in the crate.
- Consider using an exercise pen instead of a crate. Some dogs just do better with more space! And who can blame them? Crates are tiny. Exercise pens or baby-gated rooms give your dog the ability to play, sleep, drink, or even use the bathroom if you give her a puppy litter box. I used a “Puppy Palace” for Niffler and will NEVER raise a puppy without an exercise pen zone. He could run around, play, relieve himself, or curl up in the cozy crate all without hurting himself or bugging me.
- Build up your dog’s crate tolerance. You don’t start marathon training with a 25-mile run. You start with 3 miles, maybe less. If your goal is a crate-trained dog, start with 1- minute training sessions (or less in some cases). If your dog is crying in the crate, you’re moving too fast.
- That said, there are probably going to be times where life dictates another schedule. That’s where the exercise pen comes in handy!
- If your dog starts to fuss in the crate, let her out right away. Take her outside to go to the bathroom. Wait outside with her on a leash for 2 minutes. Then go back inside. Don’t scold her or play with her. You’re totally ignoring your dog, other than the fact that you’re on the other end of the leash! Just show her that crying gets her a potty break, nothing more. If she goes to the bathroom, great! If not, that’s ok too.
- This teaches your dog that she can get a bathroom break by crying (a great skill), avoids teaching your dog how to cry for hours on end, and avoids rewarding your dog with social attention for crying.
- When you return inside, give your dog something to distract her. Put her back in her crate or exercise pen, but give her something else to do. Puzzle toys are great for this.
- Only let her out of the crate for playtime or cuddles when she’s quiet. If you want, you can release your pup as soon as she quiets down. Or you can wait until the end of your nap – but try to only release her from the crate for fun times when she’s quiet. This avoids rewarding your dog for making a fuss.
Crate training can be a total drag. If you don’t travel or do dog sports, you might not really need to crate train your dog. But if crate training is a must for your house, this is how I do it.