Sarah A. writes — Hi Kayla!! I just got a new puppy, and would love your advice! I’d love to teach my puppy to stop eating everything. She seems to want to eat every single thing she finds outside. I keep having to take things from her mouth so she doesn’t choke or puncture something or ingest large amounts of grass. When I can get a treat out of my hip bag fast enough, I replace the object with a treat, so she won’t have such a negative association with me taking stuff from her.
But even still, she resists a bit, and I would rather she not eat the stuff on the first place. But I also struggle to get her attention in a way that will still allow her to calm down and go to the bathroom when we go outside. Do you have any advice on teaching a puppy to stop eating everything?
Certified Dog Behavior Consultant Sue Brown has created two excellent resources to help you with your new puppy: an $11 impulse control online mini-course, and a $67 online dog training course. Both of these options will really help you get started on controlling your puppy!
Want more personalized help? Check out our different remote and online training options here. It’s remote, on your own time, and totally personalized. Like having a trainer in your pocket!
Oh, the joy of young puppies. You’re trying to do potty training right, so you’re constantly going outside with a pocketful of treats. But your pup would rather eat grass, wrappers, bugs, twigs, or even rocks than go potty and get her treat! How do you teach a puppy to stop eating everything?
Sarah is already doing a great job by bringing treats on the walks. She’s able to distract her puppy from inedible things and then reward her for complying. But there are plenty more tricks to try to help teach her puppy to stop eating everything.
Work on drop it, leave it, and exchange games.
Both “drop it” and “leave it” are great skills for all dogs to know. They truly are lifesaving in some situations. Less dramatically, they’re the best way to puppy to stop eating everything. An exchange game is a game in which your dog learns to trade what he’s got for what you’ve got. This is useful in teaching him to drop grass/twigs/sticks in exchange for a treat. There are lots of great YouTube videos on how to teach each of these skills. In practicality on walks, this means carrying really tasty treats (cubed ham, hot dog, or lunch meat are all good places to start). Your pup will soon realize that it’s a great idea to listen to Mom!
- To get started: check out the “it’s your choice” game and “exchange games” on my blog about dog training games (there are video demos, too)
- Each of these games is a good introduction to drop it and leave it. I like to have separate cues for this. That way, I can use one cue to mean “spit that out” and another that means “don’t pick that up!” As an example of when this distinction is great to know, here’s a story:
- Today Barley and I went for a 4-mile jog. As we ran down the sidewalk under a bridge in a dingy area, we came up towards an open box of pizza. I called out “leave it!” and Barley continued to run past. If he only knew “drop it,” I’d have to get him to spit out some tasty pizza. That’s harder than just not eating the pizza in the first place. I also avoided any potential danger of toxins or whatever else is coating gross pizza on the ground. Later on the same run, he picked up a stick. That’s fine. But as he started running looking to me, tripping over himself as he tried to get me to throw the stick, I decided that he needed to stop carrying the stick and focus on our run. So I cued him to “drop it,” and he did so. It’s not a big deal for him to pick up a stick, so he didn’t need to “leave it.” But eventually I wanted him to spit it out, so I asked him to.
- This distinction isn’t always as important. If you only teach one, I’d teach “leave it.” It’s easier to ask your dog to ignore something than it is to ask your dog to spit something tasty out!
Work on impulse control.
We’ve already touched on two of my favorite impulse control games. While “it’s your choice” and exchange games are great, there’s much more to try! Impulse control is a fantastic skill for dogs to have. It sounds like your puppy is acting on her most basic impulses to explore the world with her mouth, then eats everything she finds. This isn’t uncommon.
- Teaching her to pause and look for direction from you (or even better, make the right decision on her own) should help. If she slows down and starts thinking more on walks, she’s less likely to try to eat everything. Increasing her impulse control through games will also help her listen to your cues for “drop it” and “leave it!”
Increase her exercise and enrichment elsewhere.
Puppies need a lot of potty breaks, which means a lot of time outside. There are a lot of things to eat outside. You can’t just stop walking her or only take her places that are perfectly clean of potential snacks. Instead, you can try to increase her exercise and enrichment outside of potty breaks. A wide variety of exercises like flirt poles, impulse control games, nosework, agility, shaping and training games, tug of war, and fetch is a great place to start. Don’t forget to throw in some enrichment like Kong Wobblers (throw out your food bowl and get one of these instead) and daily stuffed Kongs. Relaxation work and nosework are a must-do for high energy dogs as well.
Increased exercise and enrichment will do a few things:
- Help wear her out. Tired dogs are less naughty.
- Give her fewer opportunities to eat things by playing more games inside.
- Educate her by playing games that teach skills.
4. Make paying attention to you on walks WAY more fun than eating things.
You’re already doing a great job by carrying treats. If you’re doing clicker training, you can start clicking and treating every time your puppy looks at you. This is called a “check-in” and it’s another great skill for your dog to have. If your treats are good enough, this exercise alone will help keep your pup’s attention on you. When you hit a roadblock with your pup’s attention, try these 3 things:
- Get better treats. If kibble doesn’t work, try hot dogs. Hot dogs aren’t good enough? Try steak. Or cheese. Try anything. If nothing is helping, the environment is too challenging for your dog. It might be that you’re doing the dog equivalent of asking a 6-year-old to do algebra while at a waterpark. See #3.
- Increase your “rate of reinforcement.” Give more treats, basically. When I first start teaching dogs that pull on leash to walk politely, they get a click-and-treat for every. Single. Step. It’s exhausting, fast-paced, and intense. But it helps keep your dog really focused, and you won’t have to do it for long before you can start decreasing how often you doll out the cookies.
- Make the task easier. Many dogs ignore that leftover pizza on the ground. It takes time to build up the impulse control (see? Told you it was important!) and focus to ignore tasty snacks all over the place. Be patient and don’t sweat it if you have some setbacks. Maybe your pup loves pinecones. Don’t take her to a pine forest just yet – stay away from the tempting things until you’re sure she can handle it.
A Note on Nutrition: Sometimes, puppies eat everything in site because their stomach hurts. This can be a symptom of allergies. Consider giving your dog specially formulated foods for dogs with allergies. You might just fix the problem by changing what you feed your dog!
Last-ditch efforts: it’s possible, though unlikely, that Sarah’s puppy suffers from Pica. This is an ill-understood disorder that results in the compulsive eating of inedible things. It’s unlikely due to the puppy’s age – many puppies just eat everything they can get their mouths on because they’re puppies. But if it turns out that Sarah’s puppy never grows out of this, it’s time to get more help. Muzzle training is a good place to start for dogs with Pica because it keeps food out of their mouths. Hopefully, it doesn’t get to that point!
When (not if) Things Slip Up
It’s ok. Your puppy will get ahold of some disgusting dead fish, or a pinecone, or a pizza slice. If you feel comfortable, use your finger as a hook to remove things from your dog’s mouth. It’s important to praise heavily afterward. Ideally, you’ll then give your dog a bunch of treats or a good round of playtime. This will help keep her comfortable with your hands near her mouth. If you tackle her to remove tasty things too often, and she’ll start being suspicious of you!
In some cases, it also might be ok to just let it slide. Just a few weeks ago, Barley got a mouthful of shredded sweet potato as we walked down the street. I have no idea why there was an open box of shredded sweet potato on the sidewalk, but that’s a mystery for another day. I asked him to drop it and he lifted his head, leaving the rest of the box with just a bit of food in his mouth. By the time I tried to clean it out with my finger, he’d already swallowed. I sighed, hoped it wasn’t rancid, and we moved on. It’s ok. He was fine. (Don’t do this if what your dog ate is dangerous – in that case, get professional help to remove the object medically).
Teaching your puppy to stop eating everything doesn’t have to be a chore. If you’re really stuck, check out our options for online dog training. I can help!
Most of the ways to teach your puppy to stop eating everything are game-like. These are good skills for your pup to have anyway. Many puppies simply grow out of this alarming and frustrating stage. But in the meantime, working on increasing her impulse control, increasing exercise, and playing training games will work wonders.
Kayla is from Ashland, Wisconsin but currently lives on the Panamerican Highway. She holds a degree in biology from Colorado College and has spent years working in zoos, animal shelters, and as a private dog trainer. She is currently putting her knowledge to use as a freelance writer while she builds Journey Dog Training. She is a Certified Dog Behavior Consultant. She shares her life with her dog Barley and her boyfriend Andrew.